Australian Outlook

In this section

Episode 87: Truth and Trust in Diplomacy (Morrison vs Macron)

09 Nov 2021
By Dr Darren Lim and Allan Gyngell AO FAIIA
Parliament House, Canberra. Source: JJ Harrison https://bit.ly/3wBhw2E

In this episode, Allan and Darren discuss the role of honesty and integrity in international diplomacy.

 

 

Allan and Darren cannot resist focusing on the escalated and seemingly personal spat between Australian PM Scott Morrison and French President Emmanuel Macron over Australia’s cancellation of the French submarine contract, then followed by the launch of AUKUS. During Morrison’s recent international trip, Macron called him a liar, to which the Australian side responded by leaking details of private text messages the French president had sent the PM just days prior to the announcement. In Morrison’s words: “claims were made, claims were refuted”.

Who is in the right/wrong here? Stepping back, what is the role of honesty and integrity, or truth and trust, in international diplomacy? How much does it matter?

Along the way, Darren finds the temptation to develop a potted academic theory of a “Morrison doctrine” too strong to pass up. Let the debate begin!

We thank Mitchell McIntosh for audio editing and Rory Stenning for composing our theme music.

Relevant links

Cameron Stewart, “How Biden threw PM under the bus”, The Australian, 2 November 2021: https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/how-joe-biden-threw-scott-morrison-under-the-bus/news-story/5dde5b5f35ef17842d83a1f4d74f83a1

Samantha Maiden, “Who is really lying in Scott Morrison, Emmanuel Macron’s French submarine feud”, Daily Telegraph, 2 November 2021:  https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/business/work/who-is-really-lying-in-scott-morrison-emmanuel-macrons-french-submarine-feud/news-story/f77df0b11df50eee5d07e681a2ef749d

Phillip Coorey, “‘I don’t like losing’: Macron ‘knew’ the subs contract was in peril”, Australian Financial Review, 1 November 2021: https://www.afr.com/politics/federal/i-don-t-like-losing-macron-knew-the-subs-contract-was-in-peril-20211101-p594xr

Stephen Dziedzic and Georgia Hitch “French ambassador says leaking of text messages between Scott Morrison and Emmanuel Macron ‘unprecedented new low’”, ABC News, 3 November 2021: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-11-03/french-ambassador-jean-pierre-thebault-submarines/100590382

Jake Evans, “Scott Morrison refuses to apologise to President Emmanuel Macron after claims PM lied about submarine deal”, ABC News, 3 November 2021: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-11-03/scott-morrison-refuses-to-apologise-to-macron/100590506

Diplomacy by Harold Nicolson (Goodreads page): https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1678410.Diplomacy

Marise Payne “Inaugural Australia-France 2+2 Ministerial Consultations”, 30 August 2021: https://www.foreignminister.gov.au/minister/marise-payne/media-release/inaugural-australia-france-22-ministerial-consultations

Daniel Hurst, “Scrapping submarines deal broke trust, Macron tells Australian PM”, The Guardian, 28 October 2021: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/oct/28/france-seeks-tangible-actions-from-australia-after-submarines-row

Andrew Tillett, “Defence admits it is looking at back-up plan for French subs deal”, Australian Financial Review, 2 June 2021: https://www.afr.com/politics/federal/defence-admits-it-is-looking-at-back-up-plan-for-french-subs-deal-20210602-p57xdu

Paul Kelly, “Morrison had to hurt France to get AUKUS subs deal”, The Australian, 3 November 2021: https://www.theaustralian.com.au/commentary/morrison-had-to-hurt-france-to-get-aukus-subs-deal/news-story/7e839a998e2bb7faee42334afae724ce

Andrew Probyn, “Scott Morrison rejects French President’s criticism over handling of scrapped submarine project”, ABC News, 1 November 2021: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-11-01/scott-morrison-rejects-emmanuel-macrons-accusations-of-lying/100586680

Ben Herscovitch, “Beijing to Canberra and Back” (newsletter): https://beijing2canberra.substack.com/

Adam Tooze, “Chartbook” (newsletter): https://adamtooze.substack.com/

Heather Cox Richardson, “Letters from an American” (newsletter): https://heathercoxrichardson.substack.com/

Bill Bishop, “Sinocism” (newsletter): https://sinocism.com/

Andrew Daily “The Weekly Dish” (newsletter): https://andrewsullivan.substack.com/

American Purpose (newsletter): https://www.americanpurpose.com/

Rohit, “Why do we dislike rules so much”, Strange Loop Cannon (newsletter), 7 September 2021: https://www.strangeloopcanon.com/p/why-do-we-dislike-rules-so-much

Related Articles

The Colombian side of the Simon Bolivar Bridge. Source: Daniel Cima/CIDH https://bit.ly/3VbqteI

The Colombia and Venezuela Reset

By Professor Maria Puerta Riera
07 October 2022

On 11 August, the newly elected Colombian president, Gustavo Petro, announced the reinstatement of diplomatic relations with Venezuela. This is a vital step in improving the bilateral relationship.
The Hong Kong-flagged ship OOCL America docks at Port Melbourne. Source: Chris Phutully, Flickr

Australia and the China Slowdown

By Professor Kerry Brown
27 March 2019

As the Chinese economy starts to slow down and relations with Beijing become more challenging, Australia will need to put the lessons it has learned along the way to good use.
The ballistic missile submarine USS Maine arrives at Naval Base Guam, April 18, 2023. Source: Navy Petty Officer 1st Class Joshua M. Tolbert/https://bit.ly/3IjtJA2

AUKUS is America's Litmus Test for Integrated Deterrence

By Jada Fraser 
17 May 2023

The trilateral defence agreement between Australia, the United Kingdom, and the United States (AUKUS) will require reinventing roles and behaviours, particularly between the U.S. and Australia. Amplifying Australian power will also require incorporating more of Canberra's voice in regional strategic policy planning.